|2010||In Danger||"The Committee noted that despite a decree outlawing the exploitation and export of rosewood and ebony, Madagascar continues to provide export permits for illegally logged timber." (Unesco)|
|2007||Inscribed||Reasons for inscription|Paul Tanner (UK):
Madagascan forests provide a wonderful opportunity to see creatures you can see no where else in the world. Not just Lemurs but also other endemics such as the nocturnal “Fossa” or Malagasy Civet (photo). Amazingly, these animals are not so difficult to see!
But I was very concerned when I saw that this inscription consisted only of a number of widely dispersed “representative” areas. For us “WHS Collectors” this approach for defining WHS can lead to problems as to whether one has actually been into the inscribed site even if one has visited the whole area quite comprehensively. In 2000 we had a very successful visit to Madagscar in terms of seeing its endemics. One of our best memories was of wonderful views of the Indri Lemur in the reserve of Perinet (now called Analamazaotra Special Reserve or Andasibe). This is situated within the Atsinanana forest area which runs (or at least used to before Mankind destroyed much of it) along the eastern side of Madagascar. It is a “Special Reserve” adjacent to the Mantadia National Park which was part of the areas nominated in 2007. This reserve is without doubt one of the highlights of a visit to Madagsacar and will be visited by most tourists. You might think that all this would ensure that it would be included! If so you do not understand the ways of UNESCO and its evaluating agent IUCN!!!
IUCN was concerned that the nominated area might not actually be the “best of the best” since other areas had not been adequately studied. Often this sort of concern has led to the deferral of proposed site (seemingly ad infinitum sometimes). Luckily, on this occasion, IUCN/UNESCO have taken a more pragmatic approach:- “In particular it was agreed that the nominated property should be amended by exclusion of …..the whole of Mantadia National Park (and associated Special Reserve)”. Furthermore it is intended that this nomination be seen just as a first stage with other areas (not necessarily those excluded this time) being added later when all the appropriate management practices etc have been put in place! I wouldn’t hold your breath on this.
But where does that leave my hope to include this inscription in my “seen list”? Well, I am afraid that I can’t use my photos of an Indri since they were taken in Perinet (But I would still advise all visitors to Madagascar to try to take in this park even though it is not part of the WHS!). Luckily, however, we also visited the Ranomafana National Park - and IUCN have left this inside the agreed inscribed boundaries. We had a great evening/night visit there and managed to see pygmy and mouse lemurs by shining a torch into bushes and finding the reflections from their eyes. We also saw the Malagasy Civet (with the help of some meaty tit bits put down by the Park staff!). Next morning, a forest walk allowed us to see around half a dozen lemur species including the Golden Bamboo Lemur, first described by Western science as recently as 1987, and on the world’s “Critically endangered species” list. This was a great place for wild-life and it really would have been a shame if IUCN had allowed its rather bureaucratic concerns to hold up the inscription of this unique example of the world’s biodiversity.
Have you been to Rainforests of the Atsinanana? Share your experiences!