Els Slots

2.00 The Netherlands - 03-Sep-24 -

Although I visited the same location (Suncheonman) as the other reviewers, I have a few additional observations to share from my visit in early September 2024:

1.    Viewtower is closed for renovation: the Yongsan observatory, from where you could take the pretty sunset pictures of the salt marshes as Clyde did, has been closed for renovation since the end of last year. It is unclear for how long, but they even have the fact printed into the booklet you receive at the entrance so it will be a while. Without access to the tower, a visit is hardly worth it and I think they should at least give a discount on the entrance fee (now 10,000 Won (7 EUR) – expensive for Korean standards).

2.    Core zone fetishists will have a hard time: the inscribed area of this component only comprises coastal waters (with sediments and islands), which are underwater or all-mud depending on the tide. It’s not possible to put your foot inside. You have a view of it from the tower (when it’s open) or (like I did) you can walk the ‘World Heritage path’ which starts to the right just before the main bridge leading to the reeds boardwalk. But even from the viewpoints along that path, all you’ll see is a sea of reed.

3.    The name of the WHS is odd: even for a natural site they felt the need to add “Korean” to the English title as they do with the cultural sites to distinguish themselves from Japan and China. Also, it’s not inscribed for the Tidal Flats but for the concentrations of migratory waterbirds and mud-dwelling critters (on biodiversity criterion X only).

4.    Not many birds in September: just 3.5 months earlier I visited the Chinese Migratory Bird Sanctuaries WHS at Yancheng, a site with very similar values  – including the habitat of that little, critically endangered Spoon-billed Sandpiper. The presence of birds was much higher at the Chinese site (due to the time of the year?). 

5.    IUCN found it very poor: the landscape is very much compromised (there are agricultural fields and apartment blocks on the horizon everywhere you look inland), what is left is small and other important areas missing. Getbol part 2, 9 additional components that should strengthen the OUV, has to be submitted in 2026 ultimately as per inscription requirements.

Read more from Els Slots here.

GabLabCebu

2.50 Philippines - 14-Jun-23 -

Here to give the Getbol its first review on this site since inscription, I've included it on my June 2023 trip to Korea. I originally did not think much of these mudflats... there are already so many Eurasian migratory bird sites, I'd already seen the little mudflats in Mont Saint Michel and Itsukushima, and if the tidal variation were the star of the show, I would've much rather wanted to see the Bay of Fundy. Well, the pictures of Suncheon Bay did really look quite pretty, and as every reviewer here so far has given nothing but praise to this field of reeds, I figured it was worth fitting into my trip. Spoiler alert: it absolutely was! As a result of choosing Suncheon, however, I do not have much to add to previous reviews other than tips on how to go and a few of my personal observations.

Suncheon is a small city with huge potential for tourism, and they sure know it! At the bus stop outside the intercity bus station, you can catch a direct bus to a good selection of featured destinations that could fill up more than an entire day, including Seonamsa, Songgwangsa, Naganeupseong, and of course, Suncheonman Nature Reserve ("man" means bay). The southwestern hospitality really shines through here, especially with the tourist information officer at the station who got out and closed her booth to lead us to the bus stop a block away. Just take bus #66 (also passes the train station after about 10 minutes), and about 40 minutes away, the nature reserve sprawls over the flat opening of the bay, bisected by the same river that flows through the city. I wasted no time at the facilities by the entrance and headed straight to the bridge where you can get your first look at the vast reed fields. This is a place to just appreciate the nature around you, often looking down towards the muddy surface for a certain glimpse at the (probably) millions of crabs that call this mudflat home. My rating may look fairly low, but I will admit that the visitor experience is at least 4 stars - it's one of the best sites I've ever been to for observing its wild ecosystem up close and undisturbed, fauna going about their day as they always do. I observed crabs digging and coming out of their holes, bumping into each other, climbing reeds, and even splitting reeds to chew them... crabs are quite an icon of Suncheonman, but I'd never thought I'd be so content to watch crabs for hours. Apparently their species diversity here is also remarkable, though I'm no expert in differentiating them. The mudskippers were also so interesting to watch, especially when they jumped into the puddles when crabs approached them. And while I wouldn't count myself so lucky with the birds, I did see quite a few flocks of clearly different species fly by once in a while, as well as some white heron/egret-type birds lazing by the water. Some small brown swallow-like birds were especially noisy as they perched on the reeds by the boardwalk. Unfortunately, it was a very foggy day, so my view from Yongsan was as hazy as could be, just enough to make out the characteristic curves of the terrain depicted in others' pictures.

Suncheonman turned out to be one of my favorite spots in Korea, and I think the combination of its unique scenic beauty and up-close view of a healthy and abundant ecosystem makes it out to be the perfect place to experience the nature of the Korean coast. This is a place I'd recommend to all visitors to Korea. It may not have Everglades-level biodiversity or Serengeti-level impressiveness in its inhabitants, but I can definitely say it deserves the same level of protection, preservation, and recognition as a unique and valuable site in the world. Looking out from Yongsan, though, I had to note the vast swathes of farmland and other non-untouched lands that surrounded the reed fields and bounded the mudflats - while you're in the reeds, they seem so endless, but a bird's eye view reveals otherwise. This is but a little pocket of wilderness in a rapidly developing land, and the fractured nature of this site shows that. In fact, the IUCN raised this point against all component sites other than the Sinan Getbol, so perhaps that would be an even better site to appreciate the true OUV of the World Heritage Site. That being said, I don't regret my choice for Suncheonman in the least, as it was not only the most convenient to reach by public transport but was also a slice of wild heaven that lives up to all the praise it has gotten thus far. The Getbol is not one of the most remarkable natural World Heritage Sites, but it is one that I think everyone can enjoy and learn from, and that's all I need to know to recommend a visit here.

Philipp Peterer

3.50 Switzerland - 05-May-20 -

I visited two locations of the Tidal Flats, up for inscription in 2020 (or maybe 2021, due to coronavirus): Suncheon Bay and the Gochang Tidal Flats.

Suncheon Bay
This location is ideal and probably the best choice, when the tidal flats become a WHS. Suncheon Bay is close to Naganeupseong TWHS (worth a visit) and Seonamsa monastery WHS.

You need to visit the Suncheon Bay Ecological Park to be able to see the iconic view shown in Clyde’s and Kyle’s pictures. The ticket fee is high and you even pay for parking (very rare in Korea). The park itself is like an Ecological Disneyland. You walk on well-maintained wooden paths, there are restaurants, boat tours and a big museum. Walk to the observatory for the tidal flats where you can admire them from three different levels.

Gochang Tidal Flats
The tidal flats are rather a very long beach with remarkable high and low tide. I visited in February, but it was clear that this is where the Koreans hit the beach in summer. I started at Dongho Beach and drove down the coast along a small road. The closest WHS is Gochang Dolmen Site. Other than that it’s off the route. I specifically chose to visit this component, because I wanted to see more of this nomination than just the obligatory Suncheon Bay.
There are some restaurants, but it’s nowhere near how we exploit beaches in Europe. As it was high tide, the beach was normal sized. I saw some football goals and volleyball nets partially under water. An info sign might have explained the tidal flats, but I don’t speak Korean.

When visiting Suncheon Bay I was convinced that this deserves to be a WHS, but having in mind that the locations also include rather ordinary beaches like Gochang, I take the whole nomination with a grain of salt. My impression however might have been different, had I seen the tidal flights on low tide.

Clyde

2.50 Malta - 16-May-17 -

I visited this tentative WHS in April 2017 after a 2.5hr drive from Busan. I visited the Suncheon Bay Wetland Reserve which is also recognised as a Ramsar Wetland of International Importance.

The elevated wooden walkways without railings over the muddy tidal flats reminded me of Plitvice in Croatia. The sheer amount and variety of different species of crabs was impressive since their food supply is abundant. I also managed to spot a number of waders (also a pair of Spoon-billed Sandpipers) and warblers. The highlight species though were the mudskippers, amphibuous fish with limbs!

The reed walks and hides are pleasant but good digiscopes, binoculars and patience are required to be able to get a glimpse of the more interesting birdlife. The famous viewpoint at sunset from the Mt Yongsan Observation Platform is well worth the 1.3km uphill hike.

The mudflat area of Korea's western coast is one of the world's top five mudflats, ranked alongside the eastern coast of Canada, the eastern coast of the United States, Germany's North Sea coast, and the mudflats of the Amazon River basin. The mudflat results from the prolonged accumulation of sand or clay carried by tidal currents from the ocean seabed. It is hidden underwater during high tides and revealed during low tides.

An interesting feature of these mudflats is the purification of contaminants that flow into the ocean. After contaminants produced by factories and homes seep into the ocean, the mudflat's sedimentary layer filters them out like filter paper. The filtered substances are then broken down and cleaned by the plant and animal life of the mudflat. It is said that the purification ability of Korean mudflats is 1.5 times stronger than that of all sewage treatment plants in the country combined.

Over 70% of the oxygen on Earth is produced not by forests but in the ocean by phytoplankton through photosynthesis. Because each gram of mudflat mud contains hundreds of thousands of phytoplankton, the mudflat is able to produce more oxygen than a forest of the same area. For this reason, Korea regards these mudflats as a true natural wonder.

Kyle Magnuson

3.50 California - United States of America - 11-Jun-11 -

Upon visiting Suncheon Bay in 2011, I quickly came to the conclusion that these highly diverse tidal flats have potential for world heritage status. As one of the most beautiful natural places in Korea (in my opinion), I am now interested in visiting more "Getbol" in Korea. Besides Suncheon, there are 5-6 other major tidal flat locations in southwestern Korea (even more have been protected recently leaving potential for a future expansion). Suncheon Bay is pristine, picturesque and the most well-known. Inevitably, this results in higher developments in tourism infrastructure to manage larger numbers of visitors. The tidal flats are home to a diverse range of species, from various types of crabs, mudskippers, to a multitude of common and rare birds. Suncheon Bay was registered on the Ramsar wetland list in 2006, Muan Getbol in 2008, Seochon Getbol in 2010, Gochang - Buan were registered jointly in 2010, and lastly Jeongdo (Sinan) Getbol in 2011. Species like the Spoon-billed Sandpiper and Oriental stork are amongst the numerous endangered waterbirds that inhabit this ecosystem. The Seochon Tidal Flats do not seem original to the identified components in the 2010 TWHS, but does seem to be included now. I visited this tidal flat region on a trip to Gunsan, but was largely unaware of its importance in comparison to sites like Suncheon Bay. Most recently, the Gochang and Buan Tidal Flat has been included in the Jeonbuk West Coast UNESCO Global Geopark.

In 2019 the Migratory Bird Sanctuaries Along the Coast of the Yellow Sea was inscribed (though the recommendation by IUCN was Deferral). Yancheng is located about 520 kilometers from the Sinan Tidal Flat in Jeollanam-do, Korea. According to the respective nomination documentation and Korean Getbol description there are multiple significant differences in the adjacent ecosystems. One being, "Although broad intertidal flat zones are distributed on both shores of the Yellow Sea, the tidal range is different between the two coasts." Based on our community score for China's "Migratory Bird Sanctuaries" WHS and the IUCN evaluation, inscription may have been premature, but the overall project (phase I and phase II) are ambitious and admirable if the end result is permanent protection for these important natural ecosystems. I for one will be pleased to see more of this region registered and protected, specifically from further land reclamation, but also appreciated for its natural beauty and ecological importance.

There have been several improvements over the last decade or so specifically in visitor accommodations/experiences and access. For example the Muan Ecological Tidal Flat Center opened in 2011. The Sinan Tidal Flat & Cittaslow Center which has evolved over the years, will likely be an ideal place to visit to check off both the Jeungdo Tidal Flat (Sinan component) and the Taepyeong Saltern. Keep in mind, many of these local museums are geared toward children and the elementary age education field trips that are so frequent in Korea.

Read more from Kyle Magnuson here.