Larry F

1.50 United States - 24-Nov-21 -

Time of visit: December 2020

Duration of visit: 15 minutes

Mode of transportation: by foot from the Royal Portuguese Reading Room

Review and experience

Valongo Wharf carries important historical significance, and in the wake of the race protests and discussions in the US - my home country - in 2020, visiting the site was an emotional and touching experience in the context of slavery, Africans in the Americas, and issues of race and class. 

It intrigues me that Valongo Wharf is the smallest WHS site (as of writing in Nov 2021) and among the short list of sites selected only on Criterion VI (despite the committee's recommendation to use VI in conjunction with others). Among the several other slavery and indentured servitude sites in the VI-only list, Valongo felt forgettable and less "monumental" (amongst the giants of Goree and Auschwitz) as a reminder of the human atrocities. I struggle to identify another Cultural Criterion OUV that would be fitting for Valongo Wharf. 

My poor rating comes not as a criticism of Valongo's historical significance, but rather the opposite - for a country so heavily influenced and defined by centuries of slavery, I was disappointed that this was a standalone slavery WHS for Brazil. Sites such as Paraty/Ilha Grande and Salvador already prominently focus on its relation to slavery in Brazil. Furthermore, the site felt not well protected, and there was only a single placard detailing a few paragraphs of history on the site. Compounded with an equally confusing WHS of Rio de Janeiro (which frankly lacks highlights of "cultural landscape" but rather "natural landscape"), I'd be curious to know why the Rio de Janeiro WHS was not extended to include Valongo and the significance of slavery to Rio de Janeiro's cultural landscape. 

Jarek Pokrzywnicki

Polska - 26-Mar-20 -

Site visited just recently, March 2020. As it was already fully described by others I will add just one thing that was not underlined. Whoever visited that place prior 2011 had no chance to view the site by any means as the whole place looked completely different. By viewing google maps I found this: Google maps image

That is a view of Valongo Wharf as it looked in 2010. If the link is not working, try to place Pegman (this yellow man on Google maps) on the small unnamed road, just where the lettering of Praca Jornal do Comercio is located on the map. Instead of remnants of Valongo Wharfs you can see a street and parking place, all asphalted. Just imagine that 1-2 meters below the the surface there are ruins what is now called Valongo Wharf

Philipp Peterer

0.50 Switzerland - 23-Aug-19 -

Visit: April 2019. Ian and Walter already covered the historical background and significance of this place. So I will stick to the more practical part. Unless you are a descendant of an African slave or in any other way emotionally attached to this place, what you will find is just a very underwhelming and poorly presented 10 minutes easy tick.

I visited in 2019, almost 2 years after inscription. Other sites with few to display (e.g. Jelling) make up for that with extensive information and an interpretation center for the lack of excitement. Valongo Wharf doesn’t. The information panels are old and don’t even wear the world heritage logo. The Wharf is part of an African heritage trail and somehow it’s not given more importance than the other five stops of the trail and you rather feel like you passed by accidentally. You need too much imagination to figure out how it once looked like. Finally you will do what we all do: take pictures from different angles, read the panels and leave after around 10 minutes. Luckily Rio is a nice city. Would this place be in a more remote place, far from other WHS, I doubt many would visit. The closest to compare this site with would be the Danube Limes site in Vienna.

To get there take the L1 tram and get out at Parada dos Navios. You can also walk along the seaside, taking the (far more eye catching) Mosteiro de Sao Bento TWHS on the way and the very futuristic Museo de Amanha.

Walter

2.50 Switzerland - 15-Feb-19 -

I visited this site on my first day in Brazil, as it is easy to reach, being in central Rio de Janeiro. I was not expecting much of it, and to be fair, it was a little underwhelming. As land has been reclaimed in the harbor, the Valongo wharf lies about 350 meters inland, and it is very difficult to imagine how it used to be.
I usually don’t read too much about sites I plan to visit, trying to keep the excitement of the discovery intact. But for this site, it would have been better to research beforhand to better understand and enjoy the visit.
It consists of part of the old stone wharf in the former harbour area of Rio de Janeiro, built for the landing of enslaved Africans reaching the South American continent from 1811 onwards. An estimated 900,000 Africans arrived in South America via Valongo. In fact, they were first landed in central Rio de Janeiro for Customs, and the moved on Bom Jesus Island for quarantaine. Only after quarantaine were they taken to Valongo to be sold in slaves markets.

The site is composed of an archeological window, through which two main archaeological layers can be seem. The lowest level consists of floor pavings in pé de moleque style (irregular cut stone set directly on the sand), attributed to the original Valongo Wharf. Built in 1811, it was more a paved beach and remained in use until 1831.
In 1843, the original wharf was earthed over to build a new wharf in honor of the arrival of Princess Tereza de Bourbon, wife of the Emperor Dom Pedro II. Nowadays, the Empress Wharf makes the upper layer of the site with a little jetty, made of regular cobblestones pavement. An obelisk was also built for the Empress arrival, still standing (even though not in its original position).
In the early 20th century, the area was covered over to reclaim some 350 meter of sea. It was not until 2011 that archeological excavation was carried out to rediscover Valongo and Empress Wharfs. 

Although underwhleming at first, Valongo Wharf is an important physical trace of the arrival of African slaves on the American continent, and is an emotional tribute to thier suffering.

Ian Cade

1.50 UK - 04-May-16 -

In brief, Valongo wharf (location) is the archaeological remains of the slave trading port in Rio which was one of the major points of entry of African slaves into the Americas.

The wharf used to jut out into the harbour, but it is now quite a way from the water and there isn't a whole lot to see. The small area of archaeological ruins lies on a newly constructed square in an otherwise unassuming part of central Rio next to a Hostpital. You can sort of make out a layout. Traces of walls give some perspective but you will need some extra input to make sense of what is a really interesting site, fortunately there are some multi lingual boards around the area to help.

This interpretation shows the utterly devastating history of the wharf which really hit home when you see the numbers of people involved. The information boards gave an estimate of 500,000 people that were sold/processed on this site, which was the final grand construction in a city where it is estimated that a fifth of all African slaves in the Americas docked. It was utterly staggering for us that this specific construction was initiated in 1811, four years after this barbarous act was outlawed internationally in the British Empire.

What struck us as extra strange was that this massive level of slavery took place in a city which presented the most multicultural face of any we had ever visited.

Whilst we appreciate we didn't have a full grasp of Brazilian ethnic relationships, the utterly multiracial face Rio presented to us was something of a revelation. I live in one of the world’s more diverse cities (London) but it was still really impressive how integrated the population of Rio (and Brazil in general) felt to us as casual observers. It was therefore extra surprising that this site stood as a testament to such a heinous practice carrying on until so recently, illustrating that Brazil was the last country in the Western Hemisphere to ban slavery.

There is a lot of regeneration work going on in relation to the World Cup and the Olympics. Part of this project has been to discover the historic importance of the area, and the world heritage site proposal seems to come out of that. There is a trail that includes the Cemetery of the New Blacks, the “Fattening Houses” and the Pedra do Sol where slaves unloaded goods at the base of one of Rio's many hills. There is also the hanging gardens of Valongo which were quirky and pleasant. This whole area is closely associated with the foundation of Samba, and other cultural traditions that aim to make sense of this countries complex ethnic history.

I'm not really sure if there is enough left to qualify as Outstanding Universal Value. The site is already part of the UNESCO international slave route, and perhaps that is the appropriate level of recognition. However Rio has such a huge role in the slave trade perhaps these meagre remains are enough to illustrate the massive human cost of the trade, and a lot of money is being spent in attempting to regenerate this section of the city and tell its full story. So I wouldn’t grumble too much if they were included.

Site 3: Experience 5