Tony H.

2.00 Finland - 27-Oct-24 -

I visited in June 2024 the section of the Grand Canal that is located in central Beijing. The inscribed part there consists mostly of Houhai, Qianhai and Xihai lakes, collectively known as Shichachai lake. These lakes are very lovely place to walk around with many trees providing shade from summer sunshine. The famous Beijing hutongs surround them with plenty of shops and restaurants to look for souvenirs or taste Chinese treats. Paddle boats seemed to be a popular activity with locals along with shopping, of course.

For Grand Canal purposes the most interesting site along the lakes is Wanning Bridge (pictured). The bridge is the oldest bridge in Beijing's central axis, originally dating from 1285, but obviously renovated multiple times since then. The bridge is still in active use with busy road going over it. Next to the bridge is 2 statues of water-harnessing beasts, probably dragons. The canal is a very pretty sight, with trees lining the canal and the water is crystal clear. You can see fish swimming in the canal and bright green plants growing at the bottom of the canal. Everything is very clean and recently renovated. The information signs next to the bridge were more concentrated on its relation to the central axis than the Grand Canal. Next to the bridge you can see also remains of a watergate besides the beast statues.

Other picturesque spot along the lakes is the small bridge between Qianhai and Houhai lakes. Very short walk away from there is the Bell and Drum Towers of Beijing, which are part of the Central Axis WHS. The lakes and Wanning Bridge are definitely worth the visit while you're in Beijing and it's easy to place to tick off the Grand Canal site. However, you won't be learning anything about the canal here or it's important place in Chinese history. The massive scale of the canal is probably better to be appreciated somewhere else.

Els Slots

3.00 The Netherlands - 18-May-24 -

I may have seen glimpses of the Grand Canal before in Beijing, Suzhou and Hangzhou, but I had never visited it consciously and thus hadn’t counted it so far. Remarkably, the Chinese have pulled off an inscription in one go (a “perfect inscription”) for such a vast serial site.

In this review, I will focus on the Hangzhou sites of interest within the Jiaxing-Hangzhou section. Most of those lie some 5km north of that other Hangzhou WHS, West Lake. Only the Fengshan Water Gate, which I did not visit, is close to the city center. The main remains lie close to Gongchen Bridge. You can reach it via the blue metro line and get off at the station aptly named ‘Grand Canal’. Hangzhou’s metro network was extended significantly in 2022 but this is not shown often in English language online resources.

Things to see in this area:

• Qiaoxi Conservation Area: this was the former merchant district, which has retained (or was it rebuilt?) its traditional streets, lanes and wooden buildings. It looks quite pretty but it is also very touristy, with ‘attractions’ such as an umbrella museum.
• Gongchen Bridge (pictured): this is a fine stone arch bridge over the Grand Canal, and the most historic bridge still standing in this section.
• Grand Canal Museum: a large hall at the ‘other’ end of the Gongchen Bridge. It does tell about what the Grand Canal meant for Hangzhou: it caused it to grow into a prosperous, commercial city. The museum has only a few explanations in English and few objects of note.
• Hangzhou Fuyi Granary (indicated as ‘Fuyicang Relics Park’ on maps): at this well-preserved warehouse from 1880 mostly rice (not grain) was stored that was transported along the canal. The large riverside building consists of 3 courtyards and 3 rows of barns. The dock is also still present. You can wander around freely, some spaces are rented out to cultural organizations and artists.

These four sights will give you a general feel about the former importance of the Grand Canal in this region. You’ll also walk along the riverside for a bit when you move around from sight to sight, which is probably the best part of the visit overall. There was little traffic on the river when I was there on a Wednesday afternoon.

Another way to see this stretch of the Canal is to hop on one of the river ferries which navigate this section in about 30 minutes. Night cruises are also offered.

Read more from Els Slots here.

GabLabCebu

2.50 Philippines - 11-Oct-19 -

WHS#73

Canals are a rather frequent, maybe a tad overrepresented, subject for WHS. After all, don't they all somewhat follow the same concept? Sure, maybe one is older, another makes use of interesting locks, and so on. Sure, very few canals (on their own, not as urban landscapes or aqueducts) actually end up on the list, but maybe it's the wrong selection. It's just strange that the 2 most important canals in the world, the Panama and Suez, don't feature on the list or even on the T-list. One canal that has gotten it's rightful recognition, though, is the Grand Canal of China. This is the grandfather of regional canal systems in the world, not just in age, but in the size of its network too. This literally connected the ends of one of the greatest oldest civilizations in the world, and it's remarkable to have survived to this day, intact across the region.

When I visited Suzhou in rainy June 2019, I made sure to check out the most famous street in the city, Shantang Street. It's just a short subway ride from the main train station, and it's really close to the Lingering Garden, one of the Classical Gardens of Suzhou. Shantang is a really atmospheric commercial area, mostly because of 2 things: its centuries-old buildings and the Grand Canal. Yes, canals form the heart of Suzhou as they were the centers of trade back in the day, and that means that they are often surrounded by the most historic buildings. One can only walk a rather short section of the canalside between the main road, which runs on a bridge above the canal, and the Tonggui Bridge, after which, the street curves behind the canalside buildings. One can actually take a boat ride on the canal even all the way to Tiger Hill, but my family was more interested in having a meal, which isn't a problem in Shantang. Pretty much every historic building is occupied by a restaurant, reflecting the original commercial purpose of the canal. Though it's a touristic area, much of the food is actually of good quality and decent prices. Do have some Suzhou-style (in our restaurant, translated as "Soviet-style") noodle soup; it was so good that I almost forgot my regrets of not getting a boat ride. Just a walk around the streets is a really great experience to see the architecture and culture, even if you stray from the canal. The inscribed area, though, is just the canal itself, so a boat ride would really be recommended, especially since it can take you to sections of the canal that can't be viewed from the streets. I just settled for soaking the whole scene up from the Tonggui Bridge before the rain got so strong we just decided to head back to the train station.

Though I couldn't really observe the non-urban stretches of the canal, it's safe to say that this is one canal project that really deserves its merit. This is a project that had never been done before in an isolated civilization, and has never since been equaled. It's also a representation of the commercial character of the Chinese civilization by being the center of trade back in the day, resulting in many historic cityscapes on its shores. It is actually these historic byproducts of the canal that make a visit such a great experience because it's proof that such a great canal has had such a great impact on its surroundings. That's why the Grand Canal is such a wonder.

Michael Novins

United States - 12-Jul-17 -

In June 2017 I made a day trip by train from Shanghai Hongqiao Railway Station to Suzhou Railway Station and then took Suzhou Rail Transit to Binhe Lu Station since it was the nearest station to the Suzhou Fengqiao Scenery Spot, one of the more scenic and easily-reachable parts of the Grand Canal of China UNESCO World Heritage SIte. From the Suzhou Fengqiao Scenery Spot, it was a 30-minute walk along a canal to the Lingering Garden, one of the Classical Gardens of Suzhou. But the best site was the plate of xiaolongxia (spicy crayfish), only available during the summer season and perhaps the most flavorful dish I've ever eaten.

Juha Sjoeblom

4.50 Finland - 20-Jun-17 -

Site visited April 2017. I visited four inscribed sites of this WHS, three granaries and one proper stretch of the actual canal.

At first, when I planned my trip to China, this site looked like just a tedious tick off. But when I searched more information about it, this site became very exciting. I found many interesting Grand Canal sites which would be very nice to visit. The only limitation would be time - which places would be within reach for my itinerary. I used Luoyang as one of my bases for my day trips so there were two options for canal visits: either Zhengzhou Section of Tongji Canal or Hua County and Xun County Section of Wei Canal (Yongji Canal). The former is nearer but it would be a bit problematic to get to because there are not any clear landmarks where to take a taxi without any Chinese skills. The latter is conveniently located along the high speed railway line towards Anyang so I would be able to visit it on my way to Yin Xu site. Additionally, I would be able to tick off one more granary site. So I chose that one.

One might wonder why there are many granaries (storehouses of grain) in this kind of watery World Heritage Site. It is justified to the background that the canal is originally created for transportation of grain. The Grand Canal answered to the massive needs of agricultural empire. It solved many unbalances in society and allocation of natural resources between the different areas of the country. In the long run it became also unifying factor and means of cultural exchange to the different areas of China.

So Xun County Section of Wei Canal was my choice for the first actual Grand Canal WHS visit. According to the nomination document it is ”the most typical” and ”one of the best preserved” section of the Wei Canal. Xunxian or Xun County is nice little town that has actually quite a lot of things to see. It is easy place to reach from the city of Hebi which has high speed railway station within 30 minutes train journey from Zhengzhou. From Hebi high speed railway station I took a taxi, 20-30 minutes, to Xunxian. I had printed the Chinese name of the town from Wikipedia. I showed the print to the driver and so we were heading to Xunxian. Later on I had some problems because the driver didn’t have a clue where I wanted in Xunxian so he wanted to drop me off in some modern residential area. After some negotiations and extra yuans the driver ’understood’ where I wanted to go.

The inscribed canal section follows about three kilometres the edge of the old town of Xunxian. After that the canal continues to south about 15 kilometres towards the town of Huaxian or Hua County where the inscribed area ends. It would be possible, and also interesting, to walk all the way to Huaxian but I didn’t have time for that.

Just beside the canal is the old town wall of Xunxian or what is left of it. Along the old town the banks are made from bricks but after that the banks are earthen. It is nice to walk along the wall to the little square where is a gate to the old town. From a distance the canal looks like a picturesque place. People of the town grow vegetables on the banks and everything seem to be quite tidy. But when you get closer you can notice that the canal is very dirty and it smells bad. It is full of garbage and I even saw a dead dog floating on the water. Still there were some cheesy looking pink pedal boats to hire under the bridge.

Like I mentioned, in Xunxian there are also some other interesting places to see than two Grand Canal sites. Maybe the best known attraction is the Dapi Hill on the edge of the old town with its massive 22 metres high Buddha statue which is said to be the oldest and largest in northern China. Also the adjacent Fuqiu Hill contains some ancient Buddhist relics and temples. The main streets of the old town are recently restored and in many spots there are also some remnants of old town wall and its towers. Overall, there could be some tourism potential in Xunxian.

Liyang Granary is located also in Xunxian, about two kilometres from the canal. It was one of the most important and largest granaries in the Sui and Tang dynasties. It had an important strategic location between the Yellow River and Yongji Canal. One of the Liyang Granary’s significant features is the transformation from underground silos to aboveground warehouses.

The site is quite easy to find from the canal. Just walk through the old town and across a bigger road. Then pass a residential area to the edge of the town. When I was, according to the map, just beside the core zone I couldn't notice anything referring to WHS. It was just a field that looked like a construction site. There were not any fences so I headed to the site via a small path.

Liyang Granary is just going through a major facelift after which there should be good facilities for visitors. There were already three glass-roofed sheltering buildings for excavations and a bigger concrete building and also small entrance building. Between the buildings are wooden paths and some info signs. Otherwise, the place was under construction. Only people at the site were some construction workers but no one paid any attention to my presence. All the buildings were closed so I just watched the excavations through the glass.

Hanjia Granary is the other of two Grand Canal related granary WHS in Luoyang. The site’s actual name is ’No. 160 Site of Hanjia Granary’ which means that it is just one excavated silo or cellar of former huge imperial state granary complex which is nowadays under the city of Luoyang. It is the best preserved single cellar site with the largest storage capacity. During the Eastern Han dynasty the capital city of Luoyang was the largest grain gathering place in the country.

The site is located on an industrial area just beside the railway. The place was quite easy to find by using the map from the nomination document. I guess I was lucky that there was just some other group leaving when I entered the place. The guard asked me some money and let me in. After my visit he closed the place. Apparently the site is not open but on appointment.

Basically the site is just one cellar, unearthed in 1972, inside a sheltering building. The cellar is 11 meters in diameter and the depth is six meters. Inside the building there are also some information signs about the granary.

Huiluo Granary site is within five kilometres walking distance north east from Hanjia Granary in the suburbs of Luoyang. Busy national highway goes through the core zone. While Hanjia Granary site is just a small building, the Huiluo Granary site is quite big area with a complete granary layout and numerous cellars. On the entrance is a big stone as a mark of the Grand Canal World Heritage Site.

It was one of the large national granaries along the Grand Canal. About 200 cellars have been discovered from the site, but it has been estimated that there could have been 700 cellars at the original granary.

To my surprise the place was closed even though it was Tuesday one in the afternoon. The problem, as usual in China, is that you can't find any information about the opening times. But hey, I was in the core zone and I could see the circles on the ground through the fences! Maybe the experience couldn't have been remarkably better inside the fence.

Grand Canal is a massive site like the Great Wall. To really understand it you have do some background research and to look a bigger picture, not just single places and details. Single short canal stretches could seem a bit underwhelming but all the networks of canals form very impressive whole. It really is an important achievement of engineering. I was pleased with my visit to Xun County Section of Wei Canal. The granaries seem to be curiosities that you just want to tick off although Liyang Granary could have some potential after the renovation.

Solivagant

3.00 UK - 24-Jun-14 -

China is a “different country” every few years – even back in 1989 it was already very different from my previous visit in 1978 but some aspects had not yet changed – in particular the road system was still very poor. We had seen the hints of things to come in the form of motorway construction but, for anyone wanting to get from Suzhou to Hangzhou the 12 hour overnight boat journey along the Grand Canal was still a reasonable way to go. Today (2014) the motorway journey takes around 2 hours to cover the c 170kms and only tourists would want to take the canal route – which does indeed still seem to be available!

We had already seen the teeming life of the canal during our cycle tours around Suzhou and it was great to get in amongst it all on the boat. Our boat was packed with passengers and we had to grab a couple of bunks from the hundreds on a lower deck. The overnight schedule meant that a lot of the trip was in the dark but I remember well the evening and morning views. My attached photo, scanned from a diapositive and taken as we left Suzhou, captures well the almost continuous “traffic jam” of cargo boats, often in the form of great “snakes” of barges loaded to the gunwales with bricks, gravel, coal etc and sacks of unknown contents! It appears that China’s investment in road and rail across the intervening years has in no way reduced the use of the canal as an important means of transporting bulk goods. If you are in the area and have an overnight to “spare” it could still be an interesting journey as an alternative to yet another motorway trip!

Frederik Dawson

4.00 Netherlands - 24-Jun-14 -

Nowhere in China can show the importance of influence in socioeconomics and culture of the ancient engineering marvel of the Grand Canal than the prosperous Jiangnan Region. During my Jiangnan visit in 2011, I crisscrossed the Grand Canal and its branches many times; I saw many beautiful water towns such as Wuzhen and Zhouzhuang, however for the best part of the Grand Canal itself was in Suzhou and Yangzhou areas, the two cities that embraced the canal and became trading hub as well as cultural center. While the highlight of Suzhou is the famous classical gardens, the city old town of Pingjiang District is equally interesting with beautiful Jiangnan vernacular houses, the style that quite similar with the Huizhou style of World Heritage Site of Xidi and Hongcun villages, small canals, stone ached bridges, and rows of weeping willow tree, a very classic image of charming Chinese water towns. Pingjiang is also the last vestiges of old Suzhou that still perfectly preserves its old area with few modern revival old, styled buildings, so to be listed as World Heritage Site, for me is the good act and final completion to preserve Suzhou as one of the most beautiful cities in China. Pan Men Gate is another nominated scenic area in southwest corner of old Suzhou, the main attraction here is the fine old city gate and beautiful Ruiguang Pagoda in the nice landscape garden. However, to be honest there was nothing much to see and I spent the majority of my time looking passing boats on the canal and old Chinese men playing mahjong in the park.

Yangzhou is quite similar to Hangzhou at the quick glance. The main attraction is the beautiful Slender West Lake; actually, it is not a lake but a wider canal area. Along the lake reminded me to beautiful Hangzhou's West Lake with beautiful lakeside pavilions, arched bridges, thousands of weeping willow trees, Tibetan stupa and all elements of perfect Chinese gardens landscape. The biggest contrast between West Lake and Slender West Lake is the lake shape, because of narrower channel; it is easier to appreciate all structures along the lake in both sides in the one ride. Also because of smaller water area, bridges in Slender West Lake are easier to have more elaborated design than those bridges in Hangzhou. Anyway, apart from Slender West Lake area, Yangzhou is unable to preserve large area of old styled architectures like Suzhou can. Along the Erdao River, which was one the main city waterway, is now full of modern but nice housings. I also impressed with Yangzhou's culinary heritage, Huaiyang Cuisine, one of the four celebrated cooking styles of China, the other are Cantonese, Sichuan and Shandong. The Grand Canal plays important role on Huaiyang Cuisine development as the place of mix and match of northern and southern cooking style. I have to admit that eating in Yangzhou was one of the best meals I had in China (my favorite Chinese cooking style is Cantonese in Hong Kong and Guangdong).

Although the outstanding value of the Grand Canal is unquestionable, I am a bit skeptical of site selection by Chinese authorities. It seemed to me that the Chinese compromised Suzhou and Yangzhou's political rivalry quest to be World Heritage Site by combining both Yangzhou and Suzhou extension under the single umbrella of Grand Canal. Strangely that while decided to combine Yangzhou and Suzhou; the Chinese explicitly excluded other well-known canal towns along many Grand Canal secondary branch and shortcut which currently under the tentative site called Ancient Venetian Township in the south of Yangtze River especially for the case of Wuzhen and Nanxun which are located on important shortcut canal bypassing Jiaxing to Hangzhou. I presumed that if the Chinese let both Yangzhou and Suzhou go on, both nominations will be each other problem on comparative study, and if they decided to include Wuzhen and Nanxun in the nomination, it may cause future obstacle to other sites like Lizhi and Xitang. In my opinion, Grand Canal is not only the sophisticating World Heritage Site, but also a very sophisticating in term of tactic on planning World Heritage Site nomination.

Ian Cade

2.50 UK - 23-Dec-11 -

It looks like this site may be China's proposal in 2014. As such I decided I could attempt to get in a pre-emptive strike at what I hope may be part of the inscription. I visited the new Grand Canal park in the town of Tongzhou which is essentially a suburb of Beijing. It is here that the massive Grand Canal had its northern terminus, before goods were offloaded to be taken into Beijing proper. It seems a lot of money has been spent on making the park into a nice recreation area, and some of the local bridges are also being restored. The park has some nice touches, especially a sculpture on the ground that recreates the course of the canal and shows scenes from its illustrious history. However whilst I was there is just felt pretty windblown and desolate, the only people there were a group of school children, an elderly man flying a kite and one western tourist trying hard to fight off jet lag.

It was nice to be there though and it was interesting in an everyday off the beaten track kind of way. I can't say I have seen the best of this massive feat of engineering, but the girth of the canal was impressive. My hopes of getting onto the water were scuppered, there were no pleasure boats sailing (despite internet sources suggesting there were), the floating restaurant was closed and looking derelict and it was too windy for me even to venture out on the pedalo (at least I think that is what the bemused attendant was try to explain to me).

Houhai lake in central Beijing was part of the canal system but I am not sure if it is part of the proposal. I went there in anticipation of some nice relaxed bars around the shore line however it seems that it has had massive investment in the last few years, and it appears it is being turned into a kind of over the top tourist resort with identikit neon bars, it wasn't really to my taste. But as with many new projects in Beijing it seems that the authorities know what mass tourism wants and here they seem to be combining it with a still being constructed night market. If you are on the hunt for some laid back bars then I would recommend walking about 5 minutes further on to the area around the Drum and Bell towers, where the atmosphere was much nicer.

Perhaps venturing out to Tongzhou is not the best way to see the site, but it was an interesting excursion form the usual tourist routes of Beijing, it Houhai lake is to be included then you need not venture too far to pick up a new WHS should it be inscribed.

[Site 3 Experience 3]

maoying

australia - 16-Dec-10 -

I love this ancient wonder still in use. the most impressive one is in Hangzhou, the southern point of the canal~ river cruise, historic buildings, local restaurants and tea houses, museums along the canal (they are best museums in China, not large in size, but focus on local topics, like pottery, sword, scissor, and of course, canal), art galleries, as well as the night sightseeing. It's just awesome!!